Why Cafeteria Plans Matter: Tax Savings for Employees

Cafeteria Plans, also known as Section 125 plans, allow employees to elect certain qualified benefits on a pre-tax basis instead of receiving taxable cash compensation. These plans are governed by federal tax law and must meet specific documentation, eligibility, and nondiscrimination requirements to maintain their tax-favored status.

How Cafeteria Plans Reduce Employee Income and Payroll Taxes

When employees elect benefits through a Cafeteria Plan, the amounts contributed are generally excluded from taxable wages. This means they are typically not subject to federal income tax, and in most cases, state and local income taxes, nor are they subject to Social Security or Medicare taxes. By lowering taxable wages, Cafeteria Plan elections reduce both income tax withholding and employee payroll taxes, resulting in higher net take-home pay compared to receiving the same compensation as taxable wages. The actual tax savings depend on the employee’s marginal tax rates and the total amount contributed under the plan.

Types of Benefits That Generate Tax Savings

Common benefits offered through Cafeteria Plans include employee-paid health insurance premiums, which are excluded from both income and payroll taxes when paid on a pre-tax basis. Health Flexible Spending Accounts (FSAs) allow employees to set aside pre-tax dollars for qualified medical expenses, while dependent care FSAs provide similar tax advantages for eligible child and dependent care costs. Cafeteria Plans may also include adoption assistance, which can be excluded from taxable income up to annual statutory limits, as well as Health Savings Account (HSA) contributions for employees enrolled in qualifying high-deductible health plans. Additionally, group-term life insurance coverage may be offered, with coverage up to certain thresholds eligible for favorable tax treatment. All benefits are subject to IRS limits, eligibility rules, and plan-specific regulations that determine the extent of potential tax savings.

Compliance and Plan Limitations

To preserve tax advantages, Cafeteria Plans must comply with IRS requirements, including written plan documentation, proper employee elections, and nondiscrimination testing. Certain individuals, such as 2% S corporation shareholders, are not eligible to participate as employees. Failure to meet these requirements can reduce or eliminate tax benefits for affected participants.

Example: Single Employee in New York Earning $200,000

A single New York employee earning $200,000 who contributes $8,300 through a Cafeteria Plan for health insurance and a health FSA reduces taxable wages to $191,700. Because these contributions are excluded from federal, state, local, and payroll taxes, the employee may save approximately $3,600 to $3,900 annually, depending on marginal tax rates and wage thresholds. Actual savings will vary based on individual tax circumstances and applicable tax law.

Summary

Cafeteria Plans affect how compensation is taxed rather than the total amount of compensation earned. For higher-income employees, particularly those subject to multiple layers of taxation, pre-tax benefit elections can meaningfully reduce both income taxes and payroll taxes. Understanding how these plans work helps employees make informed benefit elections and enables employers to administer plans in compliance with federal tax rules.

Stay Updated & Support My Work

If you found this overview helpful and want to stay updated on IRS guidance, tax strategies, and financial planning insights, subscribe to my newsletter! You can also support my work with a Buy Me A Coffee—every contribution helps keep this content free, useful, and minimally ad-supported.

Subscribe to The TaxFi Brief

Support Me on BuyMeACoffee

Thanks for reading and supporting!

The information provided in this blog post is intended for general informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal or tax advice. While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information, tax laws and regulations are subject to change, and individual circumstances may vary. For personalized advice and to ensure compliance with current tax laws, it is strongly recommended that you consult with a qualified tax professional, financial advisor, or legal counsel. The author and publisher of this blog assume no responsibility for any errors or omissions, or for any actions taken based on the information contained herein.